The Complete Guide to Reselling Online: Strategies for Success on Amazon, Walmart, eBay, Whatnot, Facebook Marketplace, and Poshmark

Have you ever thought about turning a passion for finding great deals into a profitable online business? If so, you’re in the right place. Over the next few minutes, we’re going to chat about the journey of becoming an online reseller.

Whether you’re eyeing Amazon’s massive audience or the intimate vibe of Facebook Marketplace, there’s an opportunity waiting for you. We’ll break down each platform so you can decide which suits your style, how to choose the right inventory, and how deep your SKU strategy should be. So, let’s get started!

An Introduction to Online Reselling

When we talk about online reselling, we’re referring to the practice of buying products at a lower cost—often through liquidators, closeout wholesalers, pallet sales, clearance sales, or thrift shops—and then selling them on different online platforms. The beauty of reselling is that it doesn’t require you to be an expert manufacturer or have your own product line. Instead, it’s about knowing the market, sourcing quality products, and connecting with customers who are looking for great deals.

Over the years, reselling has evolved from simple garage sales to a full-blown industry that leverages sophisticated technology and analytics. Today, platforms like Amazon, Whatnot, and eBay have created massive ecosystems where even the smallest seller can reach millions of potential customers. But with opportunity comes complexity. Each platform has its own culture, rules, and best practices—and that’s what we’re here to explore.

Imagine you’re at a networking event, chatting with fellow resellers. You’d probably swap stories about how one platform is better for new items while another is a treasure trove for vintage finds. That’s exactly what this guide is about: having a friendly conversation about the ins and outs of each platform, sharing practical tips, and offering insights you can use to launch or improve your reselling business.

Understanding the Reselling Landscape

Before diving into the specifics of each platform, let’s take a moment to understand the bigger picture. At its core, reselling online is about matching supply with demand. You find products that are undervalued or that have a hidden gem of potential. Then, you present them to an audience that’s willing to pay a premium for convenience, quality, or rarity.

Inventory is key. Think of your inventory as the heart of your business. The types of products you choose—and the condition in which they’re sold—can make or break your success. Some products work best when they’re brand new, while others have a thriving market as gently used or even as refurbished items. And then there’s SKU depth—this is essentially the variety and number of distinct items you list for sale. Too few, and you might miss out on opportunities; too many, and you risk overwhelming your operations. The trick is to strike a balance that fits your business model and the platform you’re using.

Now, let’s chat about the major platforms and what makes each unique. We’re not going to be overly technical or use a lot of bullet points here—instead, imagine us discussing these over a long, relaxed conversation.

Amazon: The Giant of E-Commerce

When you think of online shopping, Amazon is usually the first name that pops into your head. Its reach is unmatched, and it’s the gold standard for many resellers. But, as with any giant, Amazon comes with its own set of challenges and opportunities.

What Makes Amazon Special?

Amazon isn’t just a marketplace; it’s a fully integrated ecosystem with everything from fulfillment services to customer analytics. If you choose to sell on Amazon, you’re tapping into a platform that’s built to optimize the customer experience. For Amazon resellers, this means access to a massive audience that trusts the brand. However, it also means you’re competing with countless other sellers, including Amazon itself, in some product categories.

Choosing the Right Products

On Amazon, customers expect high-quality, reliable products. This platform works best for items that are new or in like-new condition. Electronics, home goods, books, and even niche private-label products tend to do really well. But here’s something interesting—while new items dominate, there’s also a thriving market for refurbished and “renewed” products. If you have a knack for repairing or refurbishing gadgets, you could tap into a market that loves quality at a discount.

In my own experience (and I’m sure many resellers would agree), the key on Amazon is to focus on niches where you can excel. Trying and offering everything under the sun might be tempting, but a focused catalog often yields better results. For example, if you’re passionate about tech accessories, starting with a concentrated inventory of 50-100 SKUs in that niche might be the way to go. Over time, as you get to know your customer base and their buying habits, you can expand your inventory in a measured way.

Managing SKU Depth on Amazon

SKU depth on Amazon is an art. You need enough variety to attract different segments of the market, but not so much that you’re drowning in complexity. A good strategy is to start moderately and then adjust based on performance data. Amazon provides detailed analytics to help you understand which products are flying off the virtual shelves and which are gathering digital dust. The goal is to keep a lean, efficient inventory that can adapt quickly to customer demand.

One thing we always recommend is being diligent about listing details. Amazon’s algorithm rewards listings that are complete and optimized with relevant keywords. This isn’t just about attracting traffic—it’s about converting views into sales. The more you invest in your product descriptions, images, and pricing strategy, the better your chances of standing out in a crowded market.

Walmart: The Trusted Retail Powerhouse

Walmart has been a household name for decades, and its online marketplace is rapidly growing. Many sellers find Walmart appealing because of its quality reputation and focus on everyday essentials.

The Walmart Appeal

One thing that makes Walmart stand out is its commitment to offering products that customers trust. The platform is known for carrying household essentials, branded electronics, and general merchandise that appeal to a broad audience. If you’re looking to sell products that are in demand by everyday shoppers—think kitchen gadgets, home appliances, and popular consumer electronics—Walmart might be your ideal home.

Inventory Considerations on Walmart

Unlike Amazon, Walmart places a heavy emphasis on quality and customer service. This means that while you might have more leeway when selling refurbished items on Amazon, Walmart generally favors brand-new or like-new products. The competition here is fierce in a different way: you must ensure that every listing meets the high standards that Walmart shoppers expect.

What does this mean for your inventory? It means that you’ll want to curate a collection of products that not only are in high demand but also consistently deliver on quality. If you’re sourcing items through wholesale or liquidation channels, be extra careful to verify that the products meet Walmart’s strict guidelines. For many sellers, this might mean a more focused inventory, perhaps in the range of 30-50 SKUs initially, so you can maintain tight quality control.

SKU Strategy for Walmart

Walmart’s online platform rewards sellers who deliver a reliable, consistent experience. Because customers come to Walmart expecting quality, your listings must be detailed and error-free. For example, providing clear specifications, warranty details, and high-quality images can make a huge difference if you’re selling electronics. Think of it as telling a story about each product—one that reassures the customer that what they’re buying is exactly as described.

Managing SKU depth at Walmart often involves a more cautious approach. Unlike Amazon, which has a broader, sometimes experimental range, Walmart benefits from a more streamlined inventory. Starting with a focused range allows you to build a strong reputation in a specific category. As your confidence and sales data grow, you can gradually expand your SKU offerings, always keeping an eye on quality and customer feedback.

eBay: The Land of Unique Finds and Auctions

If you’ve ever browsed eBay, you know it’s a different world from the polished, streamlined shopping experience of Amazon or Walmart. eBay is where collectors, bargain hunters, and anyone with a taste for unique items come into play. It’s a marketplace where both new and used items find a home, and the auction-style listings add an element of excitement to every sale.

The Unique Vibe of eBay

eBay has always been about more than just transactions—it’s about the thrill of the hunt. Many sellers find that eBay is the perfect place for items that are hard to categorize: vintage clothing, rare collectibles, refurbished electronics, and even quirky, one-of-a-kind items. Because the platform accommodates both fixed-price listings and auctions, you have the flexibility to experiment with different pricing strategies.

Sourcing for eBay

One of the joys of eBay is that it welcomes a wide range of product conditions. If you’re someone who loves digging through thrift shops, garage sales, or estate sales, eBay is a playground. Items that mainstream retailers might overlook can become highly coveted treasures on eBay. The key here is honesty. Detailed descriptions, clear photos, and an honest account of any wear or defects are essential. Buyers on eBay appreciate transparency, and a well-documented item can command a premium even if it’s used.

Over the years, we’ve learned that eBay is a great platform for sellers who enjoy curating collections. If you have a particular passion—say, vintage watches or rare vinyl records—eBay can be a gold mine. You might start with a modest collection of 20-50 SKUs in your niche and then gradually expand as you build a following of dedicated buyers. Unlike the highly automated worlds of Amazon and Walmart, eBay thrives on personal connection and detailed storytelling.

Crafting Your eBay Listings

What makes an eBay listing really stand out? It’s the narrative you build around the product. Instead of just listing technical specifications, share the story behind the item. Was it a rare find at a local flea market? Does it have a unique history that adds to its charm? Buyers on eBay often appreciate a personal touch—a note that explains why this product is special can create an emotional connection and justify a higher price point.

And let’s talk about SKU depth on eBay. Because the market is so varied, you have the flexibility to experiment. Some eBay resellers thrive by focusing on a very narrow niche, while others manage a broader inventory with hundreds of SKUs. The key is to continuously monitor what sells, tweak your listings, and be willing to let go of items that aren’t performing. It’s a dynamic process that rewards creativity and adaptation.

Whatnot: Niche Collectibles and the Excitement of Live Auctions

Now, let’s switch gears and talk about Whatnot—a newer platform that’s carving out a niche for itself by focusing on collectibles and pop culture merchandise. Whatnot is not like the traditional marketplaces we’ve discussed. It’s more intimate, community-driven, and even a bit like a live auction combined with social media.

The Whatnot Experience

Whatnot is where collectors come to connect, chat, and bid on items in real-time. Imagine joining a live stream where sellers showcase limited edition trading cards, Funko Pops, sneakers, and other pop culture gems. There’s an energy to Whatnot that you don’t quite get on the bigger platforms, and it’s that energy that makes it so appealing to a younger, more engaged audience.

Finding Your Niche on Whatnot

If you’re passionate about collectibles or niche pop culture items, Whatnot might be your ideal platform. The products here aren’t just items—they’re pieces of a larger cultural conversation. When you source items for Whatnot, authenticity is paramount. Buyers are looking for rare finds that come with a guarantee of genuineness, and they’re willing to pay a premium for that assurance.

Because Whatnot caters to a specific crowd, your inventory doesn’t need to be as extensive as on Amazon or eBay. In fact, a smaller, well-curated selection can often be more effective. Think of it like hosting a private viewing at a boutique—if you have 10-30 carefully chosen SKUs that you know will excite collectors, that’s often better than a sprawling inventory that lacks focus. The conversational nature of the platform also means that building a rapport with your buyers is key. Engaging in live streams, answering real-time questions, and sharing your items’ backstory can make all the difference.

The Art of the Live Auction

One of the coolest aspects of Whatnot is the live auction. It’s not just about listing a price and waiting for a sale; it’s about creating an experience. If you’re comfortable on camera and enjoy interacting with people, live auctions can be both fun and lucrative. They allow you to showcase your passion for the items you sell, which in turn builds trust and encourages buyers to return for future events. The live format also creates a sense of urgency, prompting buyers to act quickly before their favorite items disappear.

Facebook Marketplace: The Local Connection

While many of us are drawn to the glamour of global platforms, there’s something special about Facebook Marketplace. It’s a place where community meets commerce, where you’re often dealing with buyers who are just a few miles away. This platform has a more casual vibe, and it’s a great way to start reselling if you prefer a more personal, localized approach.

The Personal Touch of Facebook Marketplace

Facebook Marketplace feels like a digital garage sale with a twist. Because it’s integrated with your Facebook profile, there’s an inherent level of trust—buyers can see who you are and even check mutual friends. This creates an environment where transactions are often more personable and less formal. For many resellers, this local connection is a major draw. It’s a chance to build community relationships and offer products catering to local tastes and needs.

Choosing Inventory for a Local Audience

On Facebook Marketplace, the types of products that do well tend to be those that people need quickly and can’t easily find elsewhere. Furniture, appliances, clothing, and even vehicles are common finds. The platform is very forgiving regarding used items—as long as you’re honest in your descriptions, buyers are usually willing to negotiate. In my own experience, the relaxed nature of Facebook Marketplace allows for a bit more creativity in how you present your items. You can write a story about the vintage dresser you’re selling or share how that gently used smartphone still has plenty of life left in it.

SKU Strategy for a Community-Focused Approach

Because Facebook Marketplace is all about local transactions, you don’t necessarily need a vast inventory. In fact, a more targeted selection often works better. Imagine having a small “boutique” of 10-20 high-demand items that you update regularly based on what’s trending in your area. This approach not only simplifies your operations but also allows you to build a reputation among local buyers. People appreciate consistency and reliability—qualities that are hard to achieve when you’re juggling hundreds of SKUs from all over the place.

One of the advantages of selling locally is that you can often bypass the complexities of shipping and returns. Buyers can inspect items in person, which means there’s less room for miscommunication about product conditions. This local intimacy also means you can often set competitive prices and negotiate face-to-face, creating a friendly, trusting atmosphere that can lead to repeat business.

Poshmark: The Fashionista’s Playground

If you have an eye for fashion and a knack for spotting trends, Poshmark might be your ideal platform. Poshmark is dedicated to fashion, accessories, and lifestyle products, and it operates almost like a social network for style enthusiasts. The emphasis is on presentation, brand, and the overall aesthetic of your offerings.

What’s So Special About Poshmark?

Poshmark has cultivated a vibrant community of fashion lovers. It’s not just about buying and selling clothes—it’s about sharing your style, getting inspired by others, and even participating in virtual “Posh Parties” where sellers and buyers mingle online. The platform is highly interactive, and it rewards creativity and personality. If you’re someone who enjoys curating outfits and sharing fashion tips, Poshmark offers a uniquely social twist on reselling.

Inventory Considerations in the Fashion World

When it comes to Poshmark, the condition is king. Most buyers expect items to be either brand new or in impeccable, gently used condition. This means that if you’re selling pre-owned clothing, it’s important to ensure everything is clean, well-maintained, and accurately described. High-end brands and designer labels tend to do particularly well on Poshmark, but there’s also a strong market for trendy, everyday pieces if you know how to market them.

Another interesting aspect of selling on Poshmark is that it often pays to be in a niche. Instead of trying to offer everything from shoes to jewelry to handbags, some of the most successful sellers focus on a particular category or style. Whether you’re an expert in vintage denim or luxury accessories, having a clear focus helps you build a loyal following. Over time, as your reputation grows, you can experiment with branching out—but it’s usually best to start with a curated selection of perhaps 30-50 SKUs that define your brand.

Engaging with the Poshmark Community

One of the reasons Poshmark stands out is its emphasis on social interaction. Buyers and sellers often form lasting connections, with many Poshmark resellers building communities around their brands. In your listings, it’s important to be personable. Share your story, talk about why you love the pieces you’re selling and engage in the comments. This isn’t just a transaction—it’s a relationship. The more genuine and approachable you are, the more likely buyers are to trust you and return for future purchases.

Managing SKU depth on Poshmark can be a balancing act. On the one hand, you want enough variety to keep your followers engaged and coming back for more. On the other hand, too many items can dilute your brand’s focus. A well-thought-out rotation—keeping your inventory fresh and aligned with the latest trends—is often the best approach.

Navigating the Journey: Tips and Stories from the Field

Throughout the world of online reselling, one lesson is universal: adaptation is key. We’ve met countless resellers who started small, learned the nuances of each platform, and gradually refined their strategies based on customer feedback and market trends. Let’s talk a bit about some of those lessons in a more conversational style.

Imagine you’re chatting with a friend who’s been in the game for a few years. They might tell you that every platform has its personality. Amazon, for instance, is like that efficient, high-powered colleague who expects everything to be done perfectly and on time. Walmart is more of a reliable family friend who always delivers quality, while eBay is that quirky, creative type who loves unique finds and stories behind each item. Whatnot, with its live auctions, feels like a vibrant social club where excitement is always in the air. Facebook Marketplace is the community bulletin board where everyone knows each other, and Poshmark is the fashion-forward friend who’s always on top of trends.

For many resellers, the journey is about experimentation. You might start with a handful of SKUs on one platform and then test the waters on another. One of our customers recently mentioned that she began by selling refurbished electronics on Amazon but discovered that her passion for vintage clothing and accessories found a more receptive audience on eBay and Poshmark. The key takeaway? Don’t be afraid to pivot. The online marketplace is vast and ever-changing, and your ability to adapt will often determine your long-term success.

Another important element is technology. Today’s reselling isn’t about manually updating spreadsheets or juggling multiple websites on your own. There are numerous tools available—inventory management software, analytics dashboards, and automated listing services—that can help you stay on top of your operations. By embracing these tools, you not only save time but also gain valuable insights into what’s working and what’s not. It’s like having a seasoned mentor by your side, guiding you through the ups and downs of the market.

Let’s also talk about customer relationships. No matter which platform you choose, trust is paramount. We’ve seen sellers build impressive businesses simply by being upfront about product conditions, responding promptly to inquiries, and standing by their return policies. Whether it’s a quick message on Facebook Marketplace or a detailed review response on Amazon, these interactions build your reputation and, over time, translate into loyal customers who spread the word about your business.

And then there’s the aspect of inventory sourcing—a topic that’s as varied as the resellers themselves. Some of us love the thrill of the hunt—scouring local thrift shops, estate sales, and clearance racks. Others prefer the predictability of wholesale channels or even dropshipping. The beauty of the reselling world is that there’s no single “right” way to source your products. Your approach should align with your personality, risk tolerance, and long-term goals. For instance, if you’re a fan of hands-on curation and enjoy the stories behind each piece, sourcing from local thrift stores might be your thing. On the other hand, if you value efficiency and scalability, building relationships with wholesalers or exploring dropshipping could be the way forward.

Finally, let’s touch on the importance of storytelling. In a digital marketplace where countless sellers are vying for attention, it’s the personal touch that can set you apart. When you share the journey behind each product—why you chose it, what makes it special, and how it fits into your brand—you’re not just selling an item, you’re offering a narrative. And narratives resonate with people. Whether you’re chatting about the vintage jacket that survived decades or the modern gadget that’s revolutionizing everyday life, let your passion shine through. It’s these stories that build connection and trust and, ultimately, drive sales.

Bringing It All Together: A Day in the Life of a Reseller

To wrap up our conversation, imagine a typical day in the life of an online reseller. The day might start with a quick check of your sales dashboard on Amazon, followed by responding to a few messages on Facebook Marketplace. Perhaps you then spend some time scrolling through eBay listings, looking for inspiration or even potential deals. Later, you might prepare for a live auction on Whatnot, making sure your collectibles are in pristine condition and that you’re ready to share their stories with an eager audience. In the evening, you update your Poshmark closet, adding new fashion finds and engaging with your community. Throughout the day, you’re juggling inventory management, customer service, and market research—all while keeping an eye on emerging trends and adapting your strategy on the fly.

This is the beauty of online reselling. It’s a dynamic, ever-changing adventure that challenges you to be resourceful, creative, and adaptable. Every day brings new opportunities and new lessons. And while the path can sometimes be daunting, the rewards—both financial and personal—are well worth the effort.

Final Thoughts

Online reselling isn’t just a way to make money—it’s a journey of discovery, learning, and personal growth. Whether you’re drawn to the vast marketplaces of Amazon and Walmart, the eclectic charm of eBay, the lively auctions of Whatnot, the community spirit of Facebook Marketplace, or the fashionable world of Poshmark, there’s a place for you in this digital ecosystem. The key is to understand the unique personality of each platform, source your inventory wisely with reliable platforms like Reseller Source, and manage your SKU depth in a way that aligns with your business goals.

Remember, there’s no one-size-fits-all approach. Some days, you might find that a focused, niche strategy works best; other times, a broad inventory with diverse offerings might be more suitable. The beauty of this industry is that it rewards experimentation and adaptation. And as you continue to learn and grow, you’ll develop a keen sense of what works—and what doesn’t.

I hope this guide has given you not only the technical insights you need but also a sense of the excitement and possibility that come with online reselling. Think of it as a conversation with a friend who’s been through the ups and downs of this business, offering tips, personal stories, and a few laughs along the way. Here’s to your success in the ever-evolving world of online reselling—may your inventory be ever-turning and your customers always be satisfied!

FAQ